top of page
Family Head

Popular Categories

Public Speaking Event

Politics

Image by Ibrahim Boran

Economics

Image by Microsoft Copilot

Lifestyle

Image by UX Indonesia

Analysis

Image by John Salvino

Geopolitics

Image by John Salvino

Civilizational Lens

Untitled-1.jpg

India's Exam Scandal Is Not a Glitch, It Is the System Working for Someone Else

13 Jun 2026

Created by

The BV Team

Administrative failure is not the case when 22.7 million students take a test and the paper is leaked before they even sharpen their pencils. It is organized, it is profitable and it is politically protected.


The moment that has become almost a ritual in the coaching belt of India. In some small town in the district, a young boy or girl perhaps the first in the family to try medicine or engineering packs a bag, takes a train, checks in at a shared hostel in Kota or Sikar or Patna and starts two or three years of that grind, total-sacrifice preparation, that the country's competitive entrance system requires. In so many ways, the family has been selling out or borrowing from someone to make a wager on a future. Later on, the morning of the exam, another body's phone rings in a WhatsApp group with the question paper.


This isn't a figure of speech. NEET-UG is the single entrance exam for admissions to undergraduate medical seats in India, which was held on 3rd May 2026 and in which 22.7 million students appeared. The exam was called off altogether by the National Testing Agency nine days later, when it emerged that the papers were being sold in advance, at ₹5 lakh a pack, later to around ₹30,000 on the eve of the test and distributed via WhatsApp groups from Nashik to Sikar. The Central Bureau of Investigation was handed the probe. Thirteen arrests were made in Dehradun and Jhunjhunu. A re-examination will be held on 21st June.


Rise in private college fees from delays


This is the second big disaster of NEET in three years. In 2024 the exam imploded in a different way not in being cancelled, but in the farce of 67 candidates achieving the top marks at the same time, with six of them from one centre scoring 100 marks under a marking scheme that made this impossible in mathematical terms. Grace marks had been awarded in a opaque fashion, the Bihar question paper leaked a day before the test and eventually the Supreme Court ordered those 1,563 candidates retest. Later that season, on hearing complaints about the leaked paper the UGC-NET was scrapped. The examination timetable of India had turned into a Calendar of Disasters!


Now, in this context, which has been replayed twice in two years, the Leader of the Opposition has declared that he will push the battle straight to the cities that have been hardest hit. Congress on June 13 said it will hold a series of student conventions starting from Kota on June 17 followed by Allahabad on July 10, Patna on July 11 and Delhi on July 14 at which Rahul Gandhi will be seen. The demand the campaign will raise explicitly involves decentralisation of NEET, abolition of examination fee, taking stringent action against paper-leak networks as well as resignation of Union minister for education Dharmendra Pradhan.


“Paper leaks are not only examination failures, they also affect the honest students and cost public money.”

This was stated by Logical Indian in May 2026.

ALLEN

COACHING

HOSTEL

RESONANCE

COACHING CENTRE

TO LET

Rooms Available

50% occupancy drop


Kota, the Coaching Capital of India, Rajasthan.


The projected losses of the coaching sector is ₹6,000 crore and 40-50% enrollment has been reduced since the NEETs were cancelled. The coaching economy in Kota, which was once estimated to be as large as ₹6,000 crore per year, is tainted by its 40–50% drop in enrollments due to the subsequent cancellation of exams and its wide-spread closure of businesses. Illustration by editorial team.

It is no coincidence that Kota was selected as the starting venue and it is not symbolic either. It's the most economically educational spot in this whole tale. Kota's name is synonymous with the national examination system; its hotels, hostels, tiffin shops, book shops and stationary shops are all revolving around coaching, which has traditionally registered between 1.5 lakh and 2 lakh students every year. Previously, in 2024, estimates had been made of nearly ₹6,000 crore loss per year for the coaching industry. Following the NEET-UG 2024 controversy, the hostels which had developed their new capacity to accommodate the demand were sitting at 25 to 50% seating occupancy. An owner of a Coral Park bakery said he had seen sales drop by 50% from what they were. But these were not the corrupt "beneficiaries" of any leak, they were the collateral damage of any leak.


Because it can get lost in the political noise, it's important to sit, and think about the economic arithmetic of this crisis. But at household level alone, the disruption costs of, say ₹1,000 to ₹2,000 per student (travel to exam centres, accommodation, rescheduled leave for accompanying parents) add up to more than ₹300 crore of immediate, unrecoverable spending, for 22.7 million registered candidates. That doesn't factor in the coaching fees which range from ₹1.5 lakh to ₹5 lakh for a two-year programme already paid by families. It does not account for the year of lost productivity due to cancellation requiring re-examination of the year. But it also doesn't account for perhaps the most obvious secondary expense: the escalation of private medical college fees as a result of the delay in admissions, which sends students who miss the cut offs for government seats to fee bands of up to ₹1 crore for an MBBS degree.


Private college fee inflation burden


There is still what no chart can show. The 23-year-old Pradeep Manich of Jhunjhunu, whose family had sold land to support his stint at the Sikar coaching school, died by suicide days after the cancellation of the 2026 exam. He is not the first that has done it. Student deaths due to the pressure of exams and exam-system failures have been piling up over the years, a tragedy which has become a black comedy of any exam scandal, with student deaths raised on a fleeting basis in Parliament and forgotten again. As per CMIE, the unemployment rate in India was 6.85% in May 2026 and the situation in urban labour markets was especially unfavourable. It is not just demoralising for the generation that was raised to believe that the only two ways to rise were by merit and a competitive exam score to hear that the exam itself is for sale. It is a destabilising of existence.


The unorganised economy which has sprung out of India's high-stakes examination system is best described as an organised crime syndicate with a business model. Reports say that the NEET paper sold for ₹5 lakh on the day before the test in 2026, but the price fell to ₹30,000 on the eve of the day of the test, indicating a price compression in a market where there was no dearth of supply. Investigators followed trails across several states and uncovered what Outlook called “solver gangs” that would help candidates get to safe houses, that would help candidates memorize answers overnight, and that worked with them on presentation. Hazaribagh in Jharkhand was identified as the venue of examination centre officials where unauthorised access to question paper trunks occurred due to the CBI probe in 2024. In some reports, the doctors and engineers were involved in multi-state syndicates laundering the proceeds through consultancies.


NEET Demand-Supply Mismatch 2026 in India.

The ratio of students to number of government seats available for MBBS (the structural cause of the demand for paper-leak):

Students registered (22.7 lakh)

Govt MBBS Seats (~1 lakh)


This is the structural root of the problem that most political commentary skirts around. About 22.7 lakh students have appeared for the exam to secure around one lakh government MBBS seats, which is around 22:1. Going to a government medical college is a difference of ₹5-10 lakh between total fees paid for a career in a government institution vs a private institution which runs into ₹80 lakh – ₹1 crore. This is not an individual personality trait of the incentive gradient to cheat. It is the all but rational reaction to a system, which has built a single tiny window for an entire generation to pass through and then has not protected it.


The coaching industry that literally grew out of this desperation is a complicating factor. The top coaching establishments in the city, such as Allen, Resonance and Vibrant Academy, train more than a lakh students annually, and their business is based on a competitive and credible exam. They are paradoxically both victims of its failure and beneficiaries of its intensity. However, the "win at all costs" mentality that are sometimes found in these institutions has always attracted their own supply of shortcuts. If each seat costs ₹1 crore, and each paper costs ₹30,000, that's a lot of margin.


The government has been on a pendulum between denial and damage control, and has failed to restore trust. Before a parliamentary standing committee, the NTA stated that it was not a "paper leak" but "irregularities and malpractices" a claim that students and parents were hardly convinced of, to say the least. The BJP members on the panel did not agree to ask for the CBI probe report to be put before the committee. The Education Ministry announced measures of relief for the re-examination. The idea of conducting a unified exam of JEE and NEET was brought up. The ministry referred to the report of the Radhakrishnan Committee on NTA reforms and 70% of the short-term recommendations had been implemented, it said. None of this has answered the question which looms over the entire exercise: how did 2026 happen if 70% of the reforms were to take place after 2024?


A Chronology of Examination Scandals 2024-2026


May 5, 2024

The NEET-UG 2024 was conducted for 24 lakh candidates. 67 topper at the same time, 6 from the same centre with 100 marks under impossible marking scheme.


June 2024

UGC-NET cancelled by Ministry of Education due to Paper Integrity Compromised. The paper is sold for ₹30-32 lakh, according to a Bihar Police report. Supreme Court issues re-test for 1,563 candidates, but rejects complete cancellation.


2024–25

The Radhakrishnan Committee makes recommendations for the reform of NTA. 70% of short-term reforms are claimed by government.


May 3, 2026

NEET-UG 2026 was conducted in 565 cities at 5,432 centres where 22.7 lakh students participated. The papers are claimed to have leaked through WhatsApp first for ₹5 lakh and later ₹30,000 on the eve of the exam.


May 12, 2026

NTA has decided to cancel NEET-UG 2026 completely. CBI probe ordered. A total of 13 persons were arrested in the two towns Dehradun and Jhunjhunu. In Sikar, Pradeep Manich commits suicide.


June 13, 2026

Congress launches a campaign for a student convention all over the country. Rahul Gandhi will now open in Kota on June 17 to go on to Allahabad, Patna and Delhi till July.


June 21, 2026

NEET-UG re-examination scheduled.


With every iteration of the crisis, the opposition's criticism has become more focused. The demand for resignation of the Education Minister has been a constant and the demand for decentralisation of NEET restoration of admission control to the states is newer and more complex from the political perspective. The NEET model is somewhat centralised and has been opposed by several states in the southern region, which have said that it is unfair for students studying in the state board system and has resulted in regional disparities. The Congress support for decentralisation matches the state-level frustrations which are not partisan. It remains to be seen whether the convention campaign can generate legislative pressure or not before the Parliament session.


The BJP's reply to this has been to name incidents of paper leaks during Congress governments the most popular of which is in Rajasthan under Gehlot to shift the blame for the supposed "systematic failure" to States under the Congress rule. One BJP spokesperson said that it was "playing politics with nothing to do with the future" of the students involved in the protest. It's not completely unfounded as a rhetorical talking point, since no major national party has a perfect record on this and several state-level exams (run by governments of all colors) have already had leak histories. The Wikipedia page on paper leaks in India is a staunchly two-sided affair. However, the centralisation of examination authority under the NTA, which was established in 2017 to introduce “standardisation and specialised management” in national testing, implies that the responsibility for the NEET 2024 and NEET 2026 is clearly at the centre, and it's hard to avoid.


The paper-leak scandal has ramifications that stretch beyond the domestic political melodrama from India's point of view. Countries that continue to produce poor credentialing systems incur a long-term reputational loss as they are seen internationally as offering poor professional degrees and credentials. Medical graduates from India are already under a microscope when it comes to licensing exams in other countries, and the fact that the Indian selection process has been flawed at times doesn't help. The physician shortage that is fueling much of the political debate of NEET (more seats, lower fees, decentralised admissions) is a true public health issue for a country with less than one doctor per thousand population in many states. Each year of re-examinations, each student forced out of the pipeline by the need for money has a downstream health infrastructure cost that is not reflected on the fiscal accounts of any single year.


As announced, what the student convention campaign would have to manage carefully, is the dichotomy between political theatre, and structural reform. If these demands are considered individually, then the ones being carried into Kota on June 17 are not unreasonable. Taking away one hurdle in the way of the poorest students would be the abolition of examination fees, which in the case of NEET is at ₹1,700. Some regional inequity could be removed through decentralisation. There is already legal possibility for criminal prosecution of leak networks and criminal prosecution of leak networks is already underway. None of these, however, addresses the shortage of seats in medical colleges, or the need to establish examining bodies that are independent of political pressure, or a long pending law to tackle the paper leak in the country, for which a lot of discussion has been taking place for a long while. The Public Examinations (Prevention of Unfair Means) Act that passed in 2024 was meant to do exactly this, however it hasn't yet been tested against syndicates that already factor in the risk of arrest when making their profits.


The point beyond the political calendar is what is extraordinary is the anger has not abated. Protests from Bhopal to Bhubaneswar and Ahmedabad to Guwahati broke out from mid-May till the first week of June 2026, mostly un-reported by national television but captured copiously on social media. The absurdist "Cockroach Janta Party" social media movement that grafted itself onto the protests in May was on target, but not in tone it was aimed straight at the disconnect between institutional accountability and political consequence. There is a constituency of students who spent years preparing for an exam that has been betrayed and they do not forget and they do not forgive easily. Their rage is as much an economic as a political fact the fact of a generation that has made a calculated investment in a promise and has found the other party in default.


This is an acknowledgment by Rahul Gandhi when he chose to make Kota the hub of this campaign. What happens after the conventions in Parliament whether it can make anything more than headlines will depend on whether the opposition can turn a student movement into a legislative momentum and whether the government can bring some accountability beyond CBI press release and re-examination dates and whether the NTA and the ministry can respond to the question, why did this happen again after 2024, which yet remains unanswered, three weeks after the re-examination was announced.


Until there is a credible answer to that question, the hostel rooms in Kota will remain reserved with a 'To Let' notice, the bakeries will be weighing up the footfall of the next semester and somewhere in a district town, no one in Delhi has heard of, a family will be considering sending the next one.

bottom of page